Effective data management is essential for businesses looking to stay competitive in an increasingly complex digital landscape. With organizations handling larger volumes of data and demanding more flexible, scalable solutions, it’s essential to choose platforms that efficiently manage data pipelines, have robust security and data governance mechanisms, ensure easy data access, and support modern architectures like data mesh or a data lakehouse.
As part of the Data Platform Bake-Off series, this article focuses on the data management capabilities of Amazon Redshift, Databricks, and Snowflake, analyzing their approaches and solutions to scalable data pipelines, access, governance and support for the increasingly vital data mesh and data lakehouse architecture.
Understanding the stakes in data management
Continue Reading
Data management forms the foundation of any organization’s analytics and decision-making processes. Efficient pipelines, accessible data, secure data governance, and a well-implemented data mesh or data lakehouse can empower businesses to harness their data effectively and optimally.
But how do Redshift, Databricks, and Snowflake stack up against each other in these areas? Let’s dive into the details.
Comparative overview of data management features
| Feature | Amazon Redshift | Databricks | Snowflake |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pipeline Setup | – AWS Glue integration for ETL – Zero-code automation | – Apache Spark-powered real-time pipelines – Advanced transformation capabilities |
– Snowpipe for near real-time ingestion – Simple data connectors but limited transformation tools |
| Data Access | – Secure role-based access via AWS IAM – Tight AWS ecosystem integration |
– Governed by Unity Catalog for metadata management, lineage tracking and access policies on the data – Provides RBAC (role-based access control) and ABAC (attribute-based access control) policies – Robust data sharing capabilities |
– Seamless data-sharing capabilities – SaaS model may limit customization – Cross-database querying support – RBAC support |
| Data Mesh Support | – Requires additional tooling to align with decentralized frameworks | – Lakehouse architecture supports flexibility – Ideal for decentralized, scalable access to data assets |
– Aligns with data-sharing principles but depends on SaaS infrastructure, potentially limiting autonomy |
| Data Mesh Support | – Requires additional tooling to align with decentralized frameworks | – Lakehouse architecture supports flexibility – Ideal for decentralized, scalable access to data assets |
– Aligns with data-sharing principles but depends on SaaS infrastructure, potentially limiting autonomy |
| Data Lakehouse Support | – Integrates with S3 via Redshift Spectrum for querying data lakes. – AWS Lake Formation adds governance. Strong AWS integration. – Scalable, cost-effective storage in S3. – AWS-dependent. – Limited AI/ML capabilities. |
– Built on Delta Lake for unified structured/unstructured data. – Real-time analytics and AI/ML support. – Open standards avoid lock-in. – Real-time and AI/ML friendly. |
– Combines data lakes and warehouses. – SaaS-based, less open than Databricks. – Simplifies analytics with strong SQL and scalability. – Proprietary model limits flexibility. – Weaker real-time processing than Databricks. |
1. Pipeline setup and data flow
Efficient data pipelines ensure that data moves seamlessly from ingestion to transformation and finally to actionable insights. Here’s how the platforms perform:
Amazon Redshift: As part of the AWS ecosystem, Redshift offers robust integration with tools like AWS Glue for Extract, Transform, and Load (ETL) processes. With its zero-ETL support, Redshift enables direct querying of operational data from sources like Amazon Aurora. This minimizes latency and simplifies data processing.
Databricks: Built on Apache Spark, Databricks shines in handling massive-scale data pipelines. Its Delta Lake technology supports real-time data streaming, ensuring pipelines are both robust and adaptable to changes in data structure or volume. This makes it ideal for machine learning and real-time analytics.
Snowflake: Snowflake’s cloud-native architecture offers simple setup for data pipelines through integration with tools like dbt and Fivetran. While its batch-oriented approach works well for structured data, it lacks the real-time streaming capabilities of Databricks, making it less suited for time-sensitive use cases.
2. Data access and sharing
Access to data—both internal and external—is a critical factor for collaboration and decision-making.
Amazon Redshift: Redshift excels in data localization within the AWS environment, offering granular control over who accesses what through AWS IAM policies. However, its focus on the AWS ecosystem can limit cross-cloud collaboration.
Databricks: Designed with data scientists and engineers in mind, Databricks provides secure and flexible data access. With support for multi-cloud environments, it caters to organizations with diverse infrastructure needs. Its Delta Sharing protocol further enhances secure data sharing across teams and partners. Unity Catalog is the premier data governance solution for pipeline and table lineage tracking, RBAC and ABAC controls and metadata management. Data sharing capabilities are slightly limited compared to Snowflake.
Snowflake: Snowflake’s data-sharing capabilities stand out, enabling seamless collaboration across organizations. Its Secure Data Sharing feature allows external parties to query shared data without requiring duplication or movement, a feature that is particularly beneficial for inter-organizational projects. Supports RBAC, superior data masking, and cross-database querying but lacks support for ABAC and query latency for masking-based queries.
3. Embracing the Data Mesh
The data mesh architecture is rapidly gaining traction as businesses move toward decentralized data ownership, enabling domain teams to handle their own data products.
- Amazon Redshift: While Redshift supports integration with AWS Lake Formation for data cataloging and governance, its centralized architecture can be limiting for fully adopting a data mesh.
- Databricks: With its support for domain-oriented data products and integration with Delta Lake, Databricks aligns well with data mesh principles. Its collaborative workspaces allow domain teams to manage their data independently while maintaining interoperability.
- Snowflake: Snowflake offers centralized governance through its Snowflake Data Cloud, but its architecture may require additional customization to fully support a decentralized data mesh model.
4. Embracing the Data Lakehouse
The data lakehouse architecture is the industry’s premier data architecture combines the scalability and flexibility of data lakes with the performance and governance of data warehouses, enabling unified data storage and analytics as well as supporting unstructured and semi-structured data types.
- Amazon Redshift: Redshift integrates with S3 and AWS Lake Formation, offering a foundation for lakehouse architecture. However, its reliance on AWS services and centralized governance may limit flexibility compared to open formats used in modern lakehouse formats like Delta Lake, Hudi, and Iceberg.
- Databricks: Built on Delta Lake, Databricks provides a robust lakehouse platform as the pioneer of the architecture with open standards, schema enforcement, data governance, and real-time analytics. Its flexibility supports diverse workloads, making it ideal for AI/ML use cases while maintaining strong governance and security combining the best parts of the data lakehouse and the data warehouse architectures respectively.
- Snowflake: Snowflake’s architecture supports lakehouse principles by combining structured and semi-structured data in a single platform. However, its proprietary SaaS model may restrict openness and flexibility compared to systems like Databricks.
Why Amazon Redshift and Databricks outperform Snowflake
While Snowflake is popular for its ease of use and strong data-sharing capabilities, Amazon Redshift and Databricks offer distinct advantages, particularly for organizations with complex and dynamic data needs.
Amazon Redshift: Superior integration and performance in AWS ecosystem
Redshift excels in its deep integration with the AWS ecosystem, making it ideal for businesses already using AWS. Its native connectivity with services like AWS Glue streamlines ETL workflows and reduces data movement, enhancing performance. Additionally, Redshift can be more cost-effective compared to Snowflake due to its seamless scaling and reduced data transfer costs within the AWS ecosystem.
Databricks: Real-Time data processing and advanced analytics
Databricks shines in real-time data processing and advanced analytics, thanks to its Apache Spark-powered Delta Lake technology. Unlike Snowflake’s batch processing, Databricks enables real-time analytics, making it ideal for machine learning, predictive analytics, and IoT data. Databricks also offers a unified platform for data engineering, science, and ML, fostering better collaboration across teams.
Key differences in Data Mesh support
Both Redshift and Databricks align better with data mesh principles than Snowflake. Redshift, with its AWS Lake Formation integration, supports decentralized data architectures, making it more flexible for businesses adopting data mesh. Databricks, with its domain-oriented data products and Delta Lake, is a leading platform for implementing data mesh, allowing teams to independently manage data assets. Snowflake, however, is more suited for centralized governance and requires customization to support a decentralized data mesh model.
Key takeaways for data-driven organizations
- Amazon Redshift is ideal for organizations heavily invested in AWS, prioritizing seamless integration and predictable ETL processes.
- Databricks excels in real-time data handling and multi-cloud adaptability, making it the go-to choice for advanced analytics and machine learning workflows.
- Snowflake stands out for ease of collaboration and external data sharing but may face limitations in real-time and decentralized scenarios.
zeb – Your trusted partner in data management
Navigating the complexities of data management requires expertise and the right tools. As an AWS Tier Partner and Databricks Partner, zeb brings unparalleled expertise in designing and implementing efficient data strategies.
Our proprietary solutions like SuperInsight, built on Databricks and AWS, enable intuitive reporting and dashboard creation powered by Generative AI. SuperInsight integrates seamlessly with your existing platforms, including Slack, Teams, Jira, and ServiceNow, enhancing collaboration and operational efficiency.
Ready to take your data management to the next level?
Partner with zeb to gain the full potential of your data platforms. Contact us today and discover how AWS Redshift and Databricks can transform your workflows.
+1 732 737 9188
sales@zeb.co